When indicated based on shared decision making with the patient, several studies have demonstrated benefit of early reconstruction. Range of motion was not affected by early verses delayed surgery: Baba (2019) <1 month, 2-3 months or >3 months; Herbst (2017) <48 hours vs after acute inflammatory phase; Bottoni (2015) <21 days vs >6 weeks; Chua (2020) <3 weeks vs > 3 weeks.
With respect to general patient satisfaction and function there was no convincing evidence that early versus later reconstruction had an impact on outcomes. Two studies (Baba 2019, Signorelli 2016) did show that instrumented laxity was less with early reconstructions compared to late reconstructions.
Regarding the presence of meniscus injury at time of ACL reconstruction several high quality studies, (Newman 2015, Anderson 2015, Mok 2019) and many lower quality studies, (Hur 2017, Everhart 2019, Baba 2019, Brambilla 2015, Keyhani 2020, Chavez 2020, Kawashima 2020, Krutsch 2017, Stone 2019, Chen 2019) showed that early ACL reconstructions had less meniscus injury than late ACL reconstructions at the time of surgery. The Newman (2015), Keyhani (2020), and Anderson (2015) studies showed that a delay of > 3 months was a predictor of more severe meniscus injury. The Everhart (2019) study showed that a delay of greater than 8 weeks resulted in an increased incidence of meniscus tears, while the Mok (2019) study showed that reconstructions performed within 12 months have fewer meniscus tears. They did not investigate whether the increased risk may have occurred prior to the 12-month point. The Kawashima (2020) study noted increased meniscus tears in reconstructions performed >5 months post-injury. Chavez (2020) noted an increase in meniscus tears in reconstructions performed >6 months after injury. The Newman (2015), Krutsch (2017), and Hur (2017) studies also showed that the meniscus injuries in the early reconstructions were more likely to be repairable then those in late reconstructions with variable definitions of early vs late reconstruction. Chen (2019) demonstrated that meniscus tears occurring after the injury MRI were increased in reconstructions performed >12 months post-injury. The Stone (2019) study found that reconstructions performed after >12 months had increased risk of subsequent medial meniscus tears. Snoeker (2020) showed that early ACL reconstruction resulted in fewer subsequent medial meniscus tears in the 5 years following surgery compared to delayed reconstruction.
With respect to the presence of articular cartilage damage at time of ACL reconstruction two high quality papers (Anderson 2015, Newman 2015) and several lower quality studies (Brambilla 2015, Chavez 2020, Everhart 2019, Kawashima 2020, Senorski 2019) showed that late ACL reconstructions had increased articular cartilage damage compared to early reconstructions at the time of surgery. The Anderson (2015) study showed this to occur as early as 3 months, while the Everhart (2019) study showed it to occur at 5 months. Brambilla (2015) showed that there was less intra-articular damage (meniscal and chondral) in reconstructions performed <3 months after injury compared to >12 months. Chavez (2020) showed increase in chondral damage if reconstruction performed > 6 months, while the Kawashima (2020) study demonstrated increased chondral damage after 5 months. Senorski (2019) showed that older patients who waited > 1 year for reconstruction had greater risk of long-term osteoarthritis.
Benefits/Harms of Implementation
Delaying ACL reconstruction after an ACL injury increases the risk of meniscal and chondral damage which could increase the risk of long-term post-traumatic osteoarthritis in the knee.
Outcome Importance
If surgical decision making includes proceeding with an ACL reconstruction after an acute ACL injury, earlier reconstruction may decrease the risk of meniscal and chondral damage in the knee, and thus long-term degenerative changes in the knee.
Cost Effectiveness/Resource Utilization
Earlier surgery does not increase cost and may decrease cost by reducing overall time in rehabilitation and recovery, with quicker return to activity, sports, and work, as well as reducing the likelihood of needing concomitant meniscal and articular cartilage procedures, which often add implant cost.
Acceptability
Younger and more active patients should be treated as expeditiously as possible for this reason. Older, less active patients who may do well with nonoperative treatment of ACL tears can be considered differently.
Feasibility
Performing ACL reconstruction within 3 months of an acute ACL tear is feasible in most settings.
Future Research
Prospective studies controlling for confounders to continue to define the ideal time for surgical intervention after an ACL injury would be valuable. Studies to assess the cost effectiveness of early versus late ACL reconstruction would also be informative.
- Anderson, A. F., Anderson, C. N. Correlation of meniscal and articular cartilage injuries in children and adolescents with timing of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2015; 2: 275-81
- Baba, R., Kondo, E., Iwasaki, K., Joutoku, Z., Onodera, J., Onodera, T., Yagi, T., Iwasaki, N., Yasuda, K. Impact of Surgical Timing on Clinical Outcomes in Anatomic Double-Bundle Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Using Hamstring Tendon Autografts. Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine 2019; 11: 2325967119880553
- Bottoni, C. R., Liddell, T. R., Trainor, T. J., Freccero, D. M., Lindell, K. K. Postoperative range of motion following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using autograft hamstrings: a prospective, randomized clinical trial of early versus delayed reconstructions. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2008; 4: 656-62
- Brambilla, L., Pulici, L., Carimati, G., Quaglia, A., Prospero, E., Bait, C., Morenghi, E., Portinaro, N., Denti, M., Volpi, P. Prevalence of Associated Lesions in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Correlation With Surgical Timing and With Patient Age, Sex, and Body Mass Index. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2015; 12: 2966-73
- Chavez, A., Jimenez, A. E., Riepen, D., Schell, B., Khazzam, M., Coyner, K. J. Anterior Cruciate Ligament Tears: The Impact of Increased Time From Injury to Surgery on Intra-articular Lesions. Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine 2020; 12: 2325967120967120
- Chen, K. H., Chiang, E. R., Wang, H. Y., Ma, H. L. Correlation of Meniscal Tear with Timing of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction in Patients without Initially Concurrent Meniscal Tear. The Journal of Knee Surgery 2019; 11: 1128-1132
- Chua, K., Kang, J. B. Y., Fook-Chong, S., Tan, A. H. C. Anterior Cruciate Ligament Surgery Performed Less Than 3 Weeks After Injury Is Not Inferior to Delayed Surgery. The Journal of Knee Surgery 2020; 0: 08
- Everhart, J. S., Kirven, J. C., Abouljoud, M. M., DiBartola, A. C., Kaeding, C. C., Flanigan, D. C. Effect of Delayed Primary Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction on Medial Compartment Cartilage and Meniscal Health. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2019; 8: 1816-1824
- Herbst, E., Hoser, C., Gfoller, P., Hepperger, C., Abermann, E., Neumayer, K., Musahl, V., Fink, C. Impact of surgical timing on the outcome of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy 2017; 2: 569-577
- Hur, C. I., Song, E. K., Kim, S. K., Lee, S. H., Seon, J. K. Early anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction can save meniscus without any complications. Indian Journal of Orthopaedics 2017; 2: 168-173
- Kawashima, I., Hiraiwa, H., Ishizuka, S., Kawai, R., Kusaka, Y., Ohtomo, K., Tsukahara, T. Incidence of Medial and Lateral Meniscal Tears After Delayed Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction in Pediatric Patients. Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine 2020; 11: 2325967120964603
- Keyhani, S., Esmailiejah, A. A., Mirhoseini, M. S., Hosseininejad, S. M., Ghanbari, N. The Prevalence, Zone, and Type of the Meniscus Tear in Patients with Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Injury; Does Delayed ACL Reconstruction Affects the Meniscal Injury?. Archives of Bone & Joint Surgery 2020; 3: 432-438
- Krutsch, W., Zellner, J., Baumann, F., Pfeifer, C., Nerlich, M., Angele, P. Timing of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction within the first year after trauma and its influence on treatment of cartilage and meniscus pathology. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy 2017; 2: 418-425
- Mok, Y. R., Wong, K. L., Panjwani, T., Chan, C. X., Toh, S. J., Krishna, L. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction performed within 12 months of the index injury is associated with a lower rate of medial meniscus tears. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy 2019; 1: 117-123
- Newman, J. T., Carry, P. M., Terhune, E. B., Spruiell, M. D., Heare, A., Mayo, M., Vidal, A. F. Factors predictive of concomitant injuries among children and adolescents undergoing anterior cruciate ligament surgery. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2015; 2: 282-8
- Signorelli, C., Filardo, G., Bonanzinga, T., Grassi, A., Zaffagnini, S., Marcacci, M. ACL rupture and joint laxity progression: a quantitative in vivo analysis. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy 2016; 11: 3605-3611
- Snoeker, B. A., Roemer, F. W., Turkiewicz, A., Lohmander, S., Frobell, R. B., Englund, M. Does early anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction prevent development of meniscal damage? Results from a secondary analysis of a randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Sports Medicine 2020; 10: 612-617
- Stone, J. A., Perrone, G. S., Nezwek, T. A., Cui, Q., Vlad, S. C., Richmond, J. C., Salzler, M. J. Delayed ACL Reconstruction in Patients >=40 Years of Age Is Associated With Increased Risk of Medial Meniscal Injury at 1 Year. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2019; 3: 584-589
- Hamrin Senorski, E., Sundemo, D., Svantesson, E., Sernert, N., Kartus, J. T., Karlsson, J., Samuelsson, K. Preoperative and Intraoperative Predictors of Long-Term Acceptable Knee Function and Osteoarthritis After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: An Analysis Based on 2 Randomized Controlled Trials. Arthroscopy 2019; 2: 489-499